CO129-100 - Sir Robinson - 1864 [9] — Page 88

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

to

Jin H. Robinson

The Rt. Struble R. Cardwell.

8 Inclosures.

No 134-

Received.

Contribution.

the demand for Military

the Colony, consequent upon

Porting proceedings in

Hongkong 1014-8

3. That the Revenue cannot

bear the Charge

85

4 That the Community is already sufficiently taxed

2

The first Argument has been defended.

It was never stated that the troops were maintained in Hongkong entirely for Colonial purposes, and the Duke of Newcastle was of opinion that it would be impossible to "carry out any plan" for making Colonies contribute to "their defence if Hongkong were excepted".

The second point has been

seriously entertained.

As

regards

the 3rd point - the insufficiency

of the Revenue to bear the Charge -

The

Duke's Despatch in June 1883 was of

this purport

opinion on

That Sir H Robinson's plea

on general grounds

was not

proven.

Estimated

At that time it was

Edit History

2026-05-19 07:25:14 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
to Jin H. Robinson The Rt. Struble R. Cardwell. 8 Inclosures. No 134- Received. Contribution. the demand for Military the Colony, consequent upon Porting proceedings in Hongkong 1014-8 3. That the Revenue cannot bear the Charge 85 4 That the Community is already sufficiently taxed 2 The first Argument has been defended. It was never stated that the troops were maintained in Hongkong entirely for Colonial purposes, and the Duke of Newcastle was of opinion that it would be impossible to "carry out any plan" for making Colonies contribute to "their defence if Hongkong were excepted". The second point has been seriously entertained. As regards the 3rd point - the insufficiency of the Revenue to bear the Charge - The Duke's Despatch in June 1883 was of this purport opinion on That Sir H Robinson's plea on general grounds was not proven. Estimated At that time it was
Baseline (Original)
to Jin H. Robinson The Rt. Struble R. Cardwell. 8 Inclosures. No 134- Received. Contribution. the demand for Military the Colorry, consequent upon Purorting proceedings in Houshong 1014-8 3. That the Revenue canust bear the Charge 85 4 That the Community is already sufficiente taxed 2 The pist Argarment has been die fernd J. was never stated that the troops wen Goland in Hongkong Entirely for Colonial purposes, and the Duke of New earth was of opinion that it would be impossible to "carry out any plan " for making Colonies contribute to "their defence if Conghony were excepted The second point has gearres been seriousf Entertained. As regards - the 3 forint - the insufficenz Wthe Resene to bear the Charge- The Ducks Opencath in June 1883 was of Sherearth opsin on That Sie It Robinsons plea outral score was non proven? Eshmated At that time it was
2026-05-19 07:25:14 · Baseline
View content

to

Jin H. Robinson

The Rt. Struble R. Cardwell.

8 Inclosures.

No 134-

Received.

Contribution.

the demand for Military

the Colorry, consequent upon

Purorting proceedings in

Houshong 1014-8

3. That the Revenue canust

bear the Charge

85

4 That the Community is already sufficiente taxed

2

The pist Argarment has been die fernd J.

was never stated that the troops wen Goland in Hongkong Entirely for Colonial purposes, and the Duke of New earth was of opinion that it would be impossible to "carry out any plan " for making Colonies contribute to "their defence if Conghony were excepted

The second point has gearres

been seriousf Entertained.

As

regards

-

the 3 forint - the insufficenz

Wthe Resene to bear the Charge-

The

Ducks Opencath in June 1883 was of

Sherearth

opsin on

That Sie It Robinsons plea

outral score

was non

proven?

Eshmated

At that time it was

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.